00:00
00:00
View Profile Spoony-McSpoon

148 Movie Reviews

43 w/ Responses

11 reviews are hidden due to your filters.

Getting better

funny yet silghtly hypocritical, many of the points made actually can reflect on this series, but none the less, to the review!

Very little seems to have been changed in the series. I thought the 'moma' responses were good but the rest was being silghtly hypocritical, for example you complain about the intelligence levels of sitcoms yet you say 'fuck that shit', not very intelligent. As for animation, it seems more jumpy than ever, it was nice to see some more orginal drawn creations though.

This series bases itself on dialogue, if it's not witty or clever then there's no point of speaking at all. Sure, shows have stupid characters, but clever things which are stupid are still said.

Sitcoms do get stale and old, which is why you don't find many long running british sitcoms, we end ours before we run out of ideas to make sure we don't release dribble, well most of the time. American sitcoms tend to be long running just to whore out money etc.

Speaking of long running series, maybe it's time you put foamy in a different direction, I've been waiting quite a while for the cartoons with more storyline and I'd hate to rush you but I think it's wise to concentrate on storyline. It'll give foamy the edge he needs.

One last thing, foamy's voice is now more annoying, I didn't think it was possible but you did it, go back to old speed please.

Thanks for reading.

Time to be kind

Firstly, all the nasty reviews for this episode have come from people who are not informed of your email conversation with a few people who shall remain nameless. I hope you get the chance to read your reviews this time, don't be upset about the few which are a bit nastier than usual, keep reading you'll find something of value ^-^
I quite liked this episode, reminds me of the early days of this series. The title 'Foamy fan amil 4' made me think 'argh, not another one' but after watching it, and thinking just how many emnails you get, I can see where you get the ideas for this one. That amount of emails is enough to drive anyone insane!
Animation wise was pretty good, it was far more than tweens. Using that amount of animation should keep you in most animators good books. I suggest not using less animation than this movie in future, since one of the rants about you is that you don't put effort into your movies. Noone can say that this movie didn't have effort put into it well I think it's difficult to animate flames, anyone you can say they can easily animate flames must be very talented.
A lot of rants about you, and I see your taking action to dissprove them which is always good to see, people can be pretty offensive on Ng as you know.
I was really against your series at one point and now I mosta pologise for some of my actions. At the time they were justified in my point of view since all the comments everyone made, I thought were true but now I know better. I think your series still isn't the greatest thing on NG, and i still find foamy annoying, so now I'll be more constructive to help you out ^-^
I hope after these next few movies you have left to submit that you start your movies with a stories idea and I wish you good luck making them.

Nice!

yay! Foamy died!

Sir-CannabisClock responds:

lol, thanks for the 10s!

This is animation!

This what animation should be like, just pure brilliance!

Ruining your own style

I just can't believe how much you are willing to change your own style! This isn't Neurotically yours anymore!
Graphics wise you managed to improve from your last few movies but it was still rather simple. the backgrounds and characters were well drawn but very lazily animated, it's not like that took you very long to make, a couple of hours tops. A few tweens and a few arm movements, very quickly produced.
Your main problem seems to be with storylines, you just can't think of any more orginal or celever ideas. The coffee shop employee seems based on a Andy Dick sketch, but heck even Andy wasn't the first person to do that idea!
I wouldn't give you such low ratings if your movies had effort put into them, these movies must be damn easy for someone with your degrees in graphics.
I'm not prejudice against you or the series, I just feel they get ratings which they don't deserve and are intentually designed to be popular.
Back to the movie, humour wise is terrible. Foamy just does his usual quick rant, Germaine does nothing and the 'employee' is just a lame excuse to make homosexually funny. I expect much better from you humour wise, it was just sinking way too low.
I know that you don't take user comments into consideration, I'm not sure why but it's most likely something to do with the amount of effort you wish to spend on an episode.
if you do something unexpected and read the reviews, please respond to a few of them. It isn't all that much to ask, people want to know if you really read these reviews and the only way to prove it is by responded so please do so.

not the world's greatest movie

I always see this movie being rated incredibly highly, I must say it was good but not the best in the world as many of your reviewers think.
The animation wasn't incredible but it works well with the style you have.
There was some humorous scenes but not there wasn't very many good jokes.
I keep noticing your movies suddenly become 1,2& 3 in portal every so often. Seems a bit fishy to me.
Overall this was a good movie but not the best thing I've ever seen on NG.

erm.....stuff

Yes, this is a movie. Have a 10!

YAY!

Another anti-foamy movie! YAY!
Making fun of foamy= all tens!
I hate foamy too :)

TobaccoClock responds:

thank you so much lostbasement :) i'm glad you liked it!

Good attempt

There is no way in hell that is frame by frame. Frame by frame is each frame drawn indivisually.
That wasn't very long for 766.7kb, you could have used the entire song for 766.7kb if you lowered the bit rate.
The characters were drawn to suit your style and look pretty good but were very easily animated. Especially if you used each character on their own layer. 2 days must not have been the full time to make it, only a few hours would be needed to animate that.
There are Five members of ACDC. I'm guessing you have intended Famine to play bass. Your bass part seems much more like the other guitar part. I know it's only a movie and it doesn't matter but you did try to animate the guitars to seem like realistic playing, even though Famine suddenly does the horns symbol whilst playing.
Characters in hoods never seem right when they are animated to sing loud voice parts. It is always best to show mouth movements in loud singing parts.
ACDC are brilliant so you get a 10 for sound, even though this doesn't do them justice.
You get a 6 for style since this doesn't fit in with the rest of the series, this is more promotional. The characters animation do fit in with each other though.
The ending could be alot better, haven't the characters suddenly get blown up is just saying that you couldn't be bothered to finish or think of a real ending.
Overall 6, a good attempt but needs some rethinking.

GooLock responds:

First of all, it is frame by frame. everything but the lights. Some is copy and pasted, but it's frame by frame. U want proof i can send the the file. Each character and light is on it's own layer, but that's it.

Second, the two days was off and on. Prolly totalled about 12 hrs for the whole movie, with like 60% of it being on death.

The characters were made because that's the way I draw characters, they were made before I intented to make movies out of them.

I had no intent to recreate ACDC, I was using their song. That's it.

The explosion ending was because all I wanted to do was the first verse/chorus. Whole song of just them on stage would be boring, at least in my opinion.

In all honesty, War's guitar was the only one i was really trying to fit the guitar part. Famine was just their cuz he was part of the group, if had a better idea at the time he would have been something other than bass.

Death was the singer because he is the leader of the group. If I wanted a more realistic/cool looking singer I would have done so, but I was keeping with the comic.

Thanks for the input anyways. I will take alot into consideration next time.

yeah!

NG needs more Creedence Clearwater Revival.

banana

Age 35, Male

Layabout

Jesus' techno colour rainy day

England

Joined on 4/29/03

Level:
26
Exp Points:
7,025 / 7,510
Exp Rank:
5,754
Vote Power:
6.73 votes
Rank:
Police Sergeant
Global Rank:
6,522
Blams:
739
Saves:
651
B/P Bonus:
12%
Whistle:
Gold
Medals:
145